Philip Gattuso with his daughter, 3-year-old Kennedy.
Philip Gattuso was a Fargo dentist whose wife had died last spring after living for 18 months with an artificial heart. When Gattuso did not pick up their 3-year-old daughter from daycare last week, a friend discovered Gattuso murdered in his condo.
On Sunday, some shithead in Oklahoma City was arrested for the murder. Gattuso once worked there and his wife was from there.
Michael Allen Nakvinda and the missing Porsche
http://www.inforum.com/event/article/id/258209/Technology, public tips and good police work led to the arrest Saturday of an Oklahoma City man in the death of a Fargo dentist who once had a practice there, police say.
The man, 41-year-old Michael Allen Nakvinda, is in an Oklahoma City jail. He may face a number of charges in Philip Gattuso’s death, Fargo police said at a Saturday night news conference.
Gattuso’s brother, Roy, said the arrest “provides some sort of closure†to the family.
Philip Gattuso, 49, was found dead in his condo at on Monday night after he didn’t pick up his 3-year-old daughter, Kennedy, at day care. The home was ransacked, and his Porsche was gone.
[...]
Witnesses in Fargo saw an extended-cab mid- to late-1990s GMC or Chevrolet pickup, dark-colored or black with tinted windows, pulling the car away from the area on Monday morning on a flatbed trailer with straps to hold the vehicle.
One tipster told police Wednesday that a pickup pulling a trailer with a car, covered by a tarp, was at a rest area about two miles south of the North Dakota/South Dakota border.
Fargo police said Saturday that video from a surveillance camera at the rest area showed an Oklahoma license plate on the trailer.
[...]
Claus said Nakvinda has an extensive criminal history, which includes felonies dating back into the 1980s.
According to the Oklahoma City Oklahoman newspaper, Nakvinda was among several members of an organized gang that were convicted for a rash of brutal 1993 home invasions.
[...]
Nakvinda pleaded guilty to numerous robbery charges and received a 10-year prison term for his role in the home invasions.
[...]
If he hadn't taken the car, they probably could never have tracked him. It was all over the news that they were looking for a Porsche Boxster being hauled by a pickup truck.
The question "Why?" remained. It seemed odd that someone would break into a home and kill someone just to steal their car.
Today's news brought another piece of the puzzle:
http://www.inforum.com/event/article/id/257800/Philip Gattuso’s father-in-law was arrested in Oklahoma Monday night, suspected of conspiring to kill his son-in-law in a reported murder-for-hire.
Fargo police wouldn’t comment Monday night on the connection between Gattuso’s dead wife’s father, 63-year-old Gene Carl Kirkpatrick, and the man charged with murder, Michael Allen Nakvinda.
But relatives of both Gattuso and the man charged with killing him said Monday that Gattuso’s in-laws know Nakvinda and are trying to get custody of Gattuso’s 3-year-old daughter after Gattuso’s wife, Valerie, died in March.
An Oklahoma City TV station, News 9, reported on Monday night that authorities there said Kirkpatrick wanted Gattuso dead because he didn’t like the way Gattuso was raising his 3-year-old daughter, Kennedy, and paid Nakvinda $3,000 to kill the 49-year-old Fargo dentist.
The Kirkpatrick family is still in custody of Kennedy and has taken court action to try to keep her, said Roy Gattuso, Philip’s brother.
“I don’t know how much sadder this situation could be,†said Roy Gattuso, who fears Kennedy is in danger.
Fargo police Lt. Pat Claus wouldn’t say if Kirkpatrick hired Nakvinda or discuss the motive for his suspected involvement in the bloody slaying of Gattuso, who died of a head injury after he was beat multiple times with a hammer.
[...]
Nakvinda’s brother-in-law, James Funderburgh, told The Forum that Nakvinda worked as a handyman in Oklahoma City and did jobs for Kirkpatrick and his wife Sharon, parents of Valerie, who died after living on an artificial heart for 18 months.
[...]
Roy Gattuso said that the Kirkpatrick family wanted his brother to give up full custody of Kennedy after his wife’s death and in the seven months since Valerie died have visited Gattuso in Fargo seven times.
Gattuso’s friends in the Fargo area were immediately suspicious of his in-laws, Roy Gattuso said, but he never suspected “anything of such a horrifying nature.â€
[...]
Roy Gattuso said the Kirkpatricks “never wanted Val out of their house†and made it difficult for his brother to visit her in Oklahoma City as she was dying.
“They have given my brother the hardest time anyone would want to have to undergo while their wife was in the hospital,†he said. “The stories are endless.â€
Roy said he’s aware of child abuse allegations the Kirkpatricks made against his brother, which he said were baseless and drove Philip Gattuso to seek psychiatric counseling.
James Funderburgh, who has been married to Nakvinda’s sister, Linna, for 23 years, said family members are “devastated†and in disbelief of the accusations against Nakvinda because “he’s not a violent guy.â€
[...]
Funderburgh said his brother-in-law is naïve and easily persuaded, and if he is responsible for Gattuso’s death, he didn’t act alone,
[...]
Funderburgh acknowledged that Nakvinda has an extensive criminal past, which includes a 10-year prison sentenced for his role in a rash of brutal home invasions in 1993.
“He was basically just a soldier in that (case),†Funderburgh said.
[...]
A bit of background on why she was in Oklahoma when she died:
http://www.inforum.com/event/article/id/257800/On Aug. 10, 2007, she underwent heart surgery to repair her mitral valve. Three days later, she was transferred to a Twin Cities hospital for post-surgery complications.
Her health continued to deteriorate as she lived on an artificial heart, said her friend, Molly Volkerding
[...]
Valerie eventually was moved to Oklahoma City to be near her family. Philip sold his Fargo practice so he could be closer to her, but under a contract with the new buyer he had to stay on for six months to treat his patients, so he commuted, his brother said.
Valerie died March 30, during that six-month period.
“That just was so hard on him, on all of us,†Molly Volkerding said. “But he immediately became the father and did everything for Kennedy.â€