PDA

View Full Version : Peace Index


brokenandtwisted
May 31st, 2007, 08:21 PM
Magazine's 'peace index' puts U.S., Iran near bottom of list, Canada near top

WASHINGTON (AP) - The United States and Iran finished in a virtual dead heat, and way down the list, in a magazine's assessment of the peacefulness of 121 countries. Canada was in the top 10 most peaceful.

The United States placed 96th and Iran came in 97th on the global index released Wednesday by the Economist magazine.

"The United States suffers because it is the world's policeman, with high levels of militarization," Andrew Williamson, the director for economic research, said in an interview.

The data were drawn from the United Nations, the World Bank, peace groups and the magazine researchers' own assessments, Williamson said.

"We are just mechanics and technicians behind the index," he said. "We are not making judgments about foreign policy."

Norway was rated as the country most at peace, followed by New Zealand, Denmark, Ireland and Japan. Canada placed eighth, behind Finland and Sweden.

Iraq was in last place, with Sudan and Israel just above.

Some two-dozen indicators were used, including wars fought in the past five years, arms sales, prison populations and incidence of crime.

"The United States arguably has kept the peace since 1945, but with a high level of defence spending," Leo Abruzzese, an editorial director for the magazine's intelligence unit, said at a news conference.

Western Europe was rated the world's most peaceful region, although France was ranked 34th and the United Kingdom 49th.

Source (http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/capress/peace_index)

Thoughts?

Killroy
May 31st, 2007, 08:51 PM
Magazine's 'peace index' puts U.S., Iran near bottom of list, Canada near top

WASHINGTON (AP) - The United States and Iran finished in a virtual dead heat, and way down the list, in a magazine's assessment of the peacefulness of 121 countries. Canada was in the top 10 most peaceful.

The United States placed 96th and Iran came in 97th on the global index released Wednesday by the Economist magazine.

"The United States suffers because it is the world's policeman, with high levels of militarization," Andrew Williamson, the director for economic research, said in an interview.

The data were drawn from the United Nations, the World Bank, peace groups and the magazine researchers' own assessments, Williamson said.

"We are just mechanics and technicians behind the index," he said. "We are not making judgments about foreign policy."

Norway was rated as the country most at peace, followed by New Zealand, Denmark, Ireland and Japan. Canada placed eighth, behind Finland and Sweden.

Iraq was in last place, with Sudan and Israel just above.

Some two-dozen indicators were used, including wars fought in the past five years, arms sales, prison populations and incidence of crime.

"The United States arguably has kept the peace since 1945, but with a high level of defence spending," Leo Abruzzese, an editorial director for the magazine's intelligence unit, said at a news conference.

Western Europe was rated the world's most peaceful region, although France was ranked 34th and the United Kingdom 49th.

Source (http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/capress/peace_index)

Thoughts?

Not too many. Using their guidelines

Abruzzese said the United States' score was pulled down by the number of wars it is involved in, large numbers of soldiers killed on the battlefield and high defense spending. He said the fact the United States has the world's largest prison population per share of overall population also pulled down the score.

I mean, come on. No shit. It's not hard to be at the top of the list when you decide to remain neutral. I mean had Norway participated in the last two World Wars like the US, would they be at the top? Not by the guidelines this "peace index" uses.

Doc
May 31st, 2007, 09:11 PM
Meh. Nothing about this is surprising at all.