PDA

View Full Version : The Keddie murders



RaVen Blackehart
December 11th, 2008, 04:49 PM
http://i37.tinypic.com/10pds41.jpg




"Cabin 28 is gone now. It's probably better that way.

According to Wikipedia, the cabin was razed in 2006. Another source indicates the cabin was destroyed in 2004. Either way, it was torn down to keep away the weirdos, the ghost hunters, and the teens testing each others' bravery.

Cabin 28 in the Keddie Resort in Plumas County, CA was destroyed to try and make way for some new memories. Anything, perhaps, to finally put the old horrors to rest.

*****

Built in 1910, the idyllic Keddie Resort offered a lodge surrounded by 33 cabins. There were hiking trails winding through the pines and great trout-fishing in the mountain streams. Customers came from miles away to dine in the restaurant at the lodge.

In the late 60s, you could buy a "Feather River Canyon Holiday [and] Keddie All-Expense Week-End (sic)" for $32 per person. The junket included "a buffet dinner and overnight accomodations at Keddie Resort."

Crime was almost unknown. Sure, in 1955 Richard Moffett and Earl Jones had an auto accident near Keddie, and the wreckage revealed that the men had stolen kitchenware from the Resort restaurant. But their injuries from the accident were probably as good a punishment as any.

Then one night in April, 1981, 15-year-old John Sharp and 17-year-old Dana Wingate hitchhiked to Keddie and Cabin 28 from nearby Quincy. John and his mom Glenna had been living in the cabin for months.

Police believe that the horrors that took place on the night of April 11 began right around the time John and Dana entered the cabin.

No one seems to know for sure if the killers entered with the boys or if they were already there. Either way, the next 10 hours or so were an orgy of violence and bloodshed.

The killers bound Glenna Sharp, John, and Dana with wire and duct tape. Tina Sharp, age 13, entered after the horrors began. She too was restrained.

The killers used knives. They used a hammer. Speaking to the San Francisco Chronicle in 2001, Plumas County Sheriff's Patrol Commander Rod DeCrona said that the victims were stabbed "so violently they bent one knife totally double from the force." DeCrona continued, "They stabbed and pounded on everything in sight -- the walls, the people, the furniture. Everything."

DeCrona said that there was "blood sprayed absolutely everywhere."

Sheila Sharp had stayed with a friend that night in a nearby cabin. She came home the next morning to discover that her home had been turned into an abbatoir. She was only 14.

But nothing in the Keddie case has ever been straightforward.

For example, Tina Sharp wasn't among the dead. She was missing.

And Tina's younger brothers -- Ricky and Greg -- were unharmed. They'd slept throughout the night in another room in the cabin, along with another boy who was there for a sleepover.

Neighbors in nearby cabins didn't hear anything that night.

At least 8 investigators were on the case in the weeks just after the massacre. Speaking to a Sacramento paper in 1984, then-Plumas Sheriff Steve Wright stated that his office had put in at least 4,000 man-hours of investigation.

They couldn't find a motive. For 3 years, they couldn't find Tina.

Just over 3 years after the murders, someone was hunting for bottles near Feather Falls, some 50 miles from Keddie, when they discovered bones.

A state lab analyzed the bones, and in June of 1984, authorities made the announcement: they'd found what was left of Tina Sharp.

*****

There have been at least two websites devoted to this nightmarish unsolved crime. One was published in conjunction with a 2005 documentary about the murders, Cabin 28: The Keddie Murders. That site has been offline for a while, and is difficult to access via the Wayback Machine. The other site is Cabin28.com.

A look at information published by Cabin28.com gives a rough sketch of some other events in the case.

Some time after April 14, 1981, police questioned two men in connection with the murders, Martin "Marty" Smartt and John "Bo" Boubede. According to the website, the Plumas County Sheriff's Dept. searched Smartt's cabin and a nearby "outbuilding." A jacket, "believed to belong to Tina [Sharp]" was found beneath the house. There may have been blood on the jacket.

[EDIT: A commenter signing off only as "Smartt" posted the following on May 28: "Please edit your blog to indicate that Marty Smartt was questioned by PCSD, the California State Police, and the FBI and was found to have no involvement with these murders and was subsequently released."]

Apparently, the investigation never went anywhere after that. John Boubede may have been dead since 1982, and Marty Smartt since 2002.

The same website states that Tina Sharp did not receive any kind of memorial or headstone until 2002.

The owner of AsylumEclectica.com took a trip to Cabin 28 in 2001. "Comtesse" made photos and wrote a short narrative. Quote:

So, we drove up Highway 70, through the beautiful Feather River Canyon, up to Keddie Resort. A short drive down Keddie Resort Road and we were in the midst of a large number of cabins, most in disrepair and featuring 'Condemned' signs on the front door. We were a bit disappointed - and surprised - to find that cabin #28 is actually located right in the middle of a group of cabins, several of which seemed to be occupied. I was expecting it to be tucked away in some dark, deep secret place where we could snoop in peace, but that was not to be. I also couldn't help but wonder how such savagery could be inflicted on several people for several hours right in the middle of this inhabited area and nobody outside heard a thing? Pretty strange...

The photos at Asylum Eclectica hold no hint of the aura of menace that must have hung over Cabin 28 in the two-plus decades following the murders there. They simply show a boarded-up, dilapidated structure that looks like nothing more than a shed, really.

Based on some discussions on a message board related to Cabin28.com, it appears as though the conflating of the mystery of Cabin 28 with The Strangers has caused some to believe that the two are one and the same, and that the story of the murders of Glenna Sharp, John Sharp, Dana Wingate, and Tina Sharp are all part of some "viral" fiction. They are not. The Keddie Murders were real, and there are newspaper articles about the murders going back to 1981, if you know where to find them. The massacre in Cabin 28 left a stain on that part of Plumas County that has pained residents ever since. While many in Plumas County would surely love for the Keddie Resort to one day be equated with something other than this bloody crime, I can't imagine they or any surviving Sharp relatives would be anything but furious to think that some folks now believe this tragedy is nothing but a marketing tool.

But you know, the Keddie Murders may remain a mystery. That's the sad fact about many long-unsolved crimes; they simply stay unsolved. In my own mental encyclopedia of unsolved mysteries, the Keddie Murders are closely related to the Groene murders in Coeur d'Alene, Idaho -- which were, of course, solved -- the murders of the Bennetts in Aurora, CO in 1984, and more recently, the murder of the Short family in Virginia in 2002. The last family murder also involved an abducted child who was only found later, miles away.

The sheer enormity of these tragedies connects them. But I sometimes think they are also connected by virtue of being examples of what happens when humans unleash their most monstrous selves. Because Joseph Edward Duncan III had a blog, we know that he was giving himself over to his psychopathic demons in the weeks before he killed the Groenes, Mark McKenzie, and took away Shasta and Dylan Groene to brutalize them for weeks on end. He was giving up and letting his mask of sanity crack and fall away."

http://www.truecrimeweblog.com/2008/05/unsolved-keddie-murders.html


http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2001/06/10/MN128511.DTL&hw=Keddie+Sharp&sn=001&sc=1000

http://www.keddiemurdersfilm.com/



YouTube - Cabin 28: The Keddie Murders trailer

Morticia
December 11th, 2008, 08:17 PM
This is the stuff nightmares are based on. It does not seem real, more like a script.

Those poor people.

Owd Scrat
December 11th, 2008, 11:18 PM
Isn't there an older thread on this case? I've read up all about it and watched all those videos.....hmmmm

Does anyone know if this is an actual case though? Or just the movie guy trying to create interest and atmosphere aka Blair Witch Project?

RaVen Blackehart
December 12th, 2008, 12:02 AM
Isn't there an older thread on this case? I've read up all about it and watched all those videos.....hmmmm

Does anyone know if this is an actual case though? Or just the movie guy trying to create interest and atmosphere aka Blair Witch Project?

It's real, the newspaper articles from back in the past prove it.

penelopejo
December 13th, 2008, 09:42 PM
No, it's real. They say that's what the strangers is based off of. That someone just walked in and killed them all. It's odd though, no one heard them scream. Understandably, it is a secluded area, but one would think they'd hear a scream being that the cabins are some what close to each other.

Silvahalo
December 13th, 2008, 11:21 PM
Absolutely horrific...

RaVen Blackehart
December 13th, 2008, 11:29 PM
No, it's real. They say that's what the strangers is based off of. That someone just walked in and killed them all. It's odd though, no one heard them scream. Understandably, it is a secluded area, but one would think they'd hear a scream being that the cabins are some what close to each other.

They were bound and gagged and couldn't scream. What gets me is, there was three kids in the bedroom, left untouched. The one, Jason, is in his early thirties now, and must remember what happened. He may have seen the whole thing and blocked out the memory or something, he is the stepson of the now deceased main suspect.

MoonandStars
March 23rd, 2009, 04:08 AM
I read the forum about this murder off and on. It can get crazy over there, but there does seem to be a renewed interest in the case with the cops. Hopefully one day, justice will be served. If anyone is interested, the forum is cabin28.com then click on message boards. They have some people related to the case posting there on a regular basis.

Insomniac
March 23rd, 2009, 09:57 AM
This is the first I've heard or read about this case. It sounds like something out of a bad horror movie.

MoonandStars
March 23rd, 2009, 11:53 AM
It really is a horrifying case. The popular sentiment is that the police and many others know who killed them. Very frustrating!

Nell
March 23rd, 2009, 12:12 PM
I read that board where the one guy was claiming to be all up in this story. It got frustrating. And now they have torn down the cabin. That was dumb IMO.

MoonandStars
March 23rd, 2009, 12:49 PM
I read that board where the one guy was claiming to be all up in this story. It got frustrating. And now they have torn down the cabin. That was dumb IMO.


It was dumb to tear it down...but they had leased it out for several years after the murders too.

That guy you're talking about is still around and there are several others who are either family members of the victims, knew them well, or are connected to suspects. It can get very frustrating over there with all of the fighting, but it's a fascinating case.

Nell
March 23rd, 2009, 12:51 PM
Even leasing it mordern forensics may have found something. But I think you are right, no one wants it solved. At least those in charge of solving it seem to not want it solved.

And yes, the fighting. AHHHHHHHHH!

MoonandStars
March 24th, 2009, 08:04 PM
One of the latest rumors Nell is that one of boys that survived that night in the cabin, is going to spill the beans when his mother passes away. They think she was there and he's waiting until she's gone to tell his true story.

Oh the drama. :dong:

RaVen Blackehart
March 24th, 2009, 08:12 PM
One of the latest rumors Nell is that one of boys that survived that night in the cabin, is going to spill the beans when his mother passes away. They think she was there and he's waiting until she's gone to tell his true story.

Oh the drama. :dong:

YouTube - deleted scene from Cabin 28: The Keddie Murders

witzah
August 18th, 2011, 12:07 AM
Joshua Sebold Staff Writer 4/19/2011

The 30-year anniversary of the infamous Keddie murders is a significant moment in Plumas County history by any measure, but the milestone seems more interesting given the release of a controversial documentary in late 2010 that markets itself as including a detailed confession to the murders.

That claim itself is in many ways symbolic of the entire documentary in that it tends to lead to more questions than answers.

April 11 marked the 30th anniversary of the 1981 crime which left Glenna "Sue" Sharp, 36; John Sharp, 15; and Dana Wingate, 17, dead; and 12-year-old Tina Sharp missing. Her partial remains were discovered near Feather Falls three years later.

The most compelling pieces of the narrative in "Cabin 28: The Keddie Murders Part II" focus on a man identified only as a Vietnam veteran named Marty, who lived very near the cabin where the murders occurred, and is clearly the primary suspect in the filmmakers' view.

If Marty was the murderer, then those interested in "justice" will be disappointed to learn that he is dead.

Marty's stepson, identified only as Justin, has long been believed by many to be the only person left alive who witnessed the murders.

Justin was one of three boys - including brothers Greg Sharp, 5, and Rick Sharp, 10 - who were miraculously left unharmed literally one room away from the most horrific murder in county history.

One of the last scenes in the movie depicts Ed Case, a college professor helping Justin write a book, explaining that the potential witness recently channeled his stepfather under hypnosis and admitted that Marty and his friend Bo, who was described by several commentators as having recently exited a veterans' mental hospital, were the culprits.

This claim is complicated by the fact that the documentary reveals Justin has changed his account of the events he witnessed that night several times throughout his life, although this last account is clearly the most interesting to an average viewer.

In many ways this contradiction sums up the entire film and the climactic report of a confession that follows later and is similarly complicated.

The film includes numerous interviews and police reports connecting the man named Marty to the crime.

His stepdaughter appears onscreen describing him as a violent and unstable person who threatened or attempted to kill her mother multiple times.

"I think he did it," she explained before responding "thank God" to the information that her stepfather was now deceased.

Police reports in the film indicate that Marty's wife contacted the police after the murders, explaining she felt her husband and Bo were both involved and that Bo liked young girls.

The last accusation alludes to the fact that one of the victims, Tina Sharp, was apparently abducted while several deceased victims were left at the scene with no attempts made to hide them. (A forensic anthropologist says in the film that Tina was killed not long after she was abducted and was not held captive for years.)

Later in the film, several police reports made by local citizens claim that Tina was pregnant.

Another woman, Nina Meeks, appears on the film explaining she was a friend of the victims and of Marty.

She said Marty was staying at her house the night after the murder and kept saying he had to get back to Keddie to "finish something," before leaving at 4 a.m. when everyone had gone to bed.

Dee Lake appears next, explaining he was a Vietnam vet and counselor for many of his peers in the county, as well as a friend of Marty's.

With tears in his eyes, Lake explained Marty told him at one point the police had 30 pieces of evidence they said connected him to the crime scene and asked him what he should do.

Lake said he didn't ask if Marty had done it and told him he should get on a bus out of town because his life would never be the same either way.

He added that in his heart he felt Marty didn't do it but while taking law classes in college he learned "murder is the one thing anybody is capable of, doesn't matter who."

"There's no criteria for it. If you look back at prior histories of people who committed the crime there is no common thread. None whatsoever. Didn't have to do with what status economically you are, ethnically like, nothing."

"Somebody got stupid, did something stupid," he concluded.

A police report soon after the crimes occurred showed Lake was interviewed by police at the time and told them he didn't think Marty was involved but he suspected Bo.

The documentary also featured audio recordings of Department of Justice interviews with Marty and Bo, both of which are extremely strange, to put it mildly.

Both men focused on very inane details of their nights, which seemed odd given the largest event to occur in the last few days before the interviews was a horrific murder.

Bo told the investigators he had only been in Keddie for a month and didn't know his way around.

He went on to claim that he couldn't even point out the cabin where the murders happened, which seems absurd given the size of the community and the amount of commotion and attention the general hysteria and police presence must have generated around cabin 28.

Marty told the detectives if he was going to kill someone he would do it more efficiently and cleanly than the murderers had.

In fact he seemed more concerned about the effect of the crime on him than the fact that his neighbors had just been mutilated.

"I'm under semi-treatment for stress, anxiety myself. I certainly don't need this, you know," he told the cops in a manner that would almost be comical if it weren't so disturbing.

The film also mentions that Marty's aunt told the police she received a strange call from him, telling her his neighbors were killed and explaining the murders in graphic detail, which made her concerned that he had lost his mind and done something to his own family.

The movie hits its peak when the filmmakers explain their discovery of a police report from relatively soon after the murders, indicating a local therapist reported that a colleague in Reno told him a man named Martin confessed to committing the Keddie murders.

The filmmakers tracked down the therapist who reportedly told his friend this story and they interviewed him.

In the interview, filmed in a darkened room, a man identified by the film crew as the same man mentioned in the police report explains he had a client at a VA hospital in Reno who sat with him through several sessions and eventually told him he killed the two female victims in the incident but not the two boys.

The therapist said Martin told him he killed the mother because she was friends with his wife and had convinced his wife to leave him.

He said Martin claimed he killed the girl because she was a witness.

The therapist told the filmmakers he reported this to the Department of Justice.

This begs the obvious question: Why the police didn't respond to this seemingly important information?

Referencing the police report about the therapist, the film explained that "there was no indication" the local police ever followed up on the report by the therapist's friend.

Even in that case, though, it seems strange that the Department of Justice wouldn't have acted on the therapist's information.

How could two police agencies, one local and one federal, miss two independent opportunities to follow up on a possible confession?

When questioned about this claim, the Plumas County Sheriff's Office allowed this reporter to view a later report, which appeared to be related to the first one.

The report indicated the therapist was interviewed by the Department of Justice in reaction to the original report.

The document explained the therapist told investigators he spoke with Martin several times but the vet never admitted to the killings, essentially denying that he told his friend he received a confession.

The report indicated Martin's wife called the therapist after the murders saying she thought Martin committed them but that Martin denied this later.

There is no way to know if the filmmakers somehow missed this second report or why it wasn't included in the film, but it seems to significantly blur the picture presented in the film.

We are left with three pieces of evidence: a report indicating a friend of a therapist was told that a confession occurred, a report indicating the therapist told the police there was no confession, and a modern-day interview with the therapist saying he did receive a confession and told the authorities about it.


http://plumasnews.com/home/8130-thirty-years-later-have-the-keddie-murders-been-solved.html

EAGLE LEAF
September 12th, 2011, 11:34 AM
I remember this story....horrible horrible crime...still scares the daylights out of me