What started as a man reluctantly admitting he was drunk when he accidentally shot his daughter to death ended with courtroom outbursts Wednesday and the girl's mother and aunt being arrested.
Kelley, facing more than 20 years in prison on the original manslaughter charge and other charges, was balking on a plea deal offering a six-year sentence, the minimum possible. Assistant Hamilton County Prosecutor Mark Piepmeier said prosecutors only offered the minimum because Kristina Lanza demanded the most lenient sentence possible for her boyfriend.
During a break for Kelley to consider the offer, family members and friends of Kelley and Lanza argued aggressively with Piepmeier, saying the proposed six-year sentence for killing the girl was too harsh. One husband and wife were kicked out of court; the wife, who created an uproar in the hall, was arrested.
When court resumed, Kelley pleaded guilty to reckless homicide and was sentenced by Common Pleas Court Judge Nadine Allen to the minimum sentence of six years in prison despite Lanza and Danielle Lott, the girl's aunt, insisting Kelley deserved a lesser sentence.
"I know Shanti would have forgave her daddy," the dead girl's mother told the judge. "This was a total accident."
That upset the judge, who didn't back down from the raised voices and taunts.
"Does anybody think that guns shot in residential neighborhoods don't go into buildings?" Allen asked Lanza.
"You're saying things that are foolish ... That's a stupid remark."
After Kelley was taken from court, several members of the Lanza family startedmouthing off. The judge warned them to behave and be quiet while leaving – or else.
Seconds later, an explosion of noise in the hall resulted in the judge calling the group back in. She scolded Lott – who had screamed "No justice served!" as she left the courtroom the first time – and Lanza and cited them for contempt, ordering them jailed. That resulted in more wailing and bedlam from the rest of the Lanza clan and their friends in the audience.
"I've handled dozens and dozens of child murders in my career," Piepmeier said. "This is the first time I've ever had the mother of a murder victim tell me we're treating the person that killed her child too harshly.
"It just makes you scratch your head sometimes, makes you wonder where people are coming from."
Shanti was the second of Kelley's children to be shot and killed. His son, David Gill, 16, died after a 2012 triple shooting.