Man Murdered Woman Then Ate Her Brains With A Glass Of Her BloodParents Charged After Their Dead Baby Found Rotting In Baby SwingBoy Fatally Stabbed Himself As His Mother Beat Him With Extension CordTeen Posted Selfies With Murdered Teacher Before Killing Self With Circular SawWoman Killed After 12-year-old Boy Jumps From Overpass In Suicide AttemptMan Used Kik Messaging App To Share Child Porn Of His 1-Year-Old StepdaughterMan Accused Of Severely Beating Toddler Because She Interrupted Video GameTeen Girl Killed Newborn By Shoving Rock Down Baby's ThroatElderly Man Killed Himself With Chainsaw After Attacking His Wife With HatchetWoman Smothered Daughter For Talking Back, Tossed Body In Dumpster

Kyle DubeBANGOR, ME —Earlier this month we reported that 20-year-old Kyle Dube had been charged with the murder of 15-year-old Nichole Cable. Yesterday an affidavit reveals that Nichole died after Kyle intended to kidnap Nichole, hide her and then find her so he could be deemed a hero. Unfortunately for Nichole, Kyle is an idiot who accidentally killed her in the process.

Nichole went missing on Mother’s Day after leaving her home to meet someone she had met on Facebook named Bryan Butterfield. A week later, after receiving information from several sources, police found Nicole’s dead body in a wooded area. The following day, Kyle Dube was charged with intentional and knowing murder.

At the time we first reported on this, there were not a lot of details regarding the relationship between Kyle and Nichole. The information in the affidavit fills in some of those blanks. Turns out Kyle had made sexual advances towards Nichole, but Nichole had turned him down. Kyle then created a fake Facebook profile using someone else’s identity and began communicating online with Nichole.

Nichole Cable

Nichole Cable

On the day she went missing, Kyle used the fake “Bryan Butterfield” account to get Nicole to meet him at the end of her street so she could get some weed. Kyle had no intentions of doing this, as it was just a way to get Nichole out of her house and inact the first stage of his stupid plan.

As she walked down the street, Kyle jumped out of the bushes, restrained Nichole with duct-tape and then put her in his father’s pickup truck. According to the affidavit, his plan was to leave her in the woods and then find her later, becoming the local hero in the process.

But when he got to the location he planned to leave her, he found that Nichole was dead. An official cause of death still has not been revealed, aside from it being labelled a homicide, but it sounds like she may have suffocated after Kyle duct-taped her face. He placed Nichole in the woods, covered her with sticks, and then threw her clothes out the window as he drove back. He told this story to both his brother and his girlfriend, who relayed the information to police.

Police also contacted the real Butterfield who told them he suspected Kyle had made a fake Facebook account using his name. Police were able to trace the IP address for the fake Butterfield’s Facebook page to the home where Kyle lived with his parents. So far, no information has been released regarding the relationship between Butterfield, Kyle and Nichole.

Kyle Dube is being held without bail at the Penobscot County Jail. If Kyle is convicted of murder, he faces between 25 years and life in prison. A lot of these details are from an affidavit using info from what Kyle says happened. While I have no doubt someone would kidnap a chick just to rescue her, as we just had a story in the news where a guy staged an armed robbery to impress his date, this just sounds like someone coming up with a story to make his motives seem less sinister.

Help The Dreamin Demon go ad free! Support us on Patreon!
Tags: , , , , ,


The views expressed in the comments are those of the comment writers and don't represent the views or opinions of D'D or its staff. Feel free to flag comments that may violate conditions outlined in our Disclaimer.

  • What a fucking idiot…..

  • that sounds like a load of shit to me..i mean really.

  • this is why i am always snooping on my kids though..because kids are prone to believing anything they read/hear, and i dont want anything bad to happen to them. except for the extra mouthy one..maybe.

  • Buffettgirl

    Hey Hero, way to fuck it all up for everyone…

  • So sad. Why are men in northern Maine like Bobby Hill or Charles Manson?! Ugh.

  • newstarshipsmell

    Let’s all pray that this “hero” becomes An Hero.

  • Jessica Stewart

    Maybe he should’ve spent a leeeetle more time researching on how to NOT kill someone when you kidnap them, and less time putting together a fake FB profile. Also….how did this chick not spot a fake FB profile? I assume the kids these days are all studied up on what a real one looks like? Are analytical skill sets no longer encouraged?

  • NY_Mommy

    I agree Morbod cuz the bullshit ain’t addin’ up. After she turned down his advances he made the fake account and lured her out? What was his plan after that? Makes no sense. Unless she was in on the ridiculous scheme, I don’t see how this could have ever worked?

  • Poor girl…

  • Reen B

    From what I’ve read so far he made the fake account in Bryan Butterfield’s name, who was an IRL friend of hers (thus, the parents probably weren’t suspicious). She didn’t meet him online. Glenburn is pretty rural, houses have long wooded driveways. She was supposed to meet “Bryan” at the end of her driveway. Before she could get there the fake Bryan (Kyle) jumped out of the woods to grab her. He was wearing a ski mask. So my theory is he planned to stay anonymous, rape her, then change back to himself to “rescue” her. That would have been feasible, except since she was unclothed, I imagine he accidentally suffocated her either with the tape or by holding her down while raping her. 🙁

  • Kyle Dube Accidentally Killed Nichole Cable While Staging a Kidnapping –

  • Jimbo11

    He looks like that other psycho, Austin Sigg. One small step from the food chain.

  • SillyCynic

    I don’t think he cared that she died, at all. I think she was a piece of experimental meat for him to get laid, and he had “0% chance of getting caught.” The duct tape was just to get her to shut up and not talk. Kinda like “Se7en”.

  • weneedhelpnow

    Accidentally killed her? As if her death was beyond his control? This was no accident.

  • Exodus

    This actually makes allot more sense, if you want your free ride to a resort such as prisons in America but don’t want a permanent check in, you need to change the charge from 1st Degree to 2nd degree murder, the word accident with the lousy story to convince a judge it “wasn’t” intentional will have him free in 10-20 years max! Proven method on using the system.

  • Junior

    Right wing little dicks will proclaim that she deserved to be murdered because she enjoyed smoking week.

  • sugarpie

    Ummm, excuse me, but if you kidnap someone with a plan to go back and find them later, don’t you think they could spoil your heroic plan by identifying you? Just saying. Unless of course I missed the fact that he threw a bag over her head. Either way, he’s a douche.

  • JohnQknowitall

    Kidnap someone to be a hero by finding her? I am guessing she didn’t see who he was or maybe that was the problem…. BUT why were her clothes not found worn by her body? There was sex – dead or alive or both.

  • SillyCynic

    Quit being a douche.

    ‘People that don’t believe in socialism think she deserved it…because this is a completely logical statement, also known as a logical fallacy…see, it has ‘logical’ in the name.’

  • DeweyCheatam

    Week? Wait. What? I thought it was weed she was after. What’s this new-fangled “week” shit and where can I get some?

  • Buffettgirl

    How in the HELL is this political??? By the way Fucktard, I’m a weed smoking right wing conservative and I sure as shit don’t think she deserved what happened to her… what now ass clown?

  • 18th40

    You wanna talk to a dude named ‘weekend’ apparently the stuff just follows him around.

  • Andrea Pizzuto

    Not only does he LOOK like a neandertal, he plans like one.

  • Reen B

    Comment of the day!!

  • Reen B

    Somewhere I read he had a ski mask on.

  • annaflixion

    I’m with Morbid, I just don’t buy it at all, especially with her being naked. Also, look at that smug look on his face. The only part that went ‘wrong’ in his mind is where he got caught. I’m willing to bet the rest of it went exactly like he wanted it to.

  • Chinchillazilla

    Even if she couldn’t ID him, it wouldn’t take an FBI criminal profiler to suspect the guy she turned down, who then “happened” to “find” her (which would involve opening the trunk of an abandoned car in the woods… why would you?).

  • Smells like bullshit, ayup.

  • I find it amusing that folks believe centralized government control (Socialist, progressives and the modern version of big government GOP) is better than individual responsibility.

  • techsupp0rt

    Riiiight…. fake.

    If you kidnap someone against their will, it is not fake. It’s just regular kidnapping.

  • RT @dreamindemon: Kyle Dube Accidentally Killed Nichole Cable While Staging a Kidnapping –

  • Kiki

    Accidentally killed my ass. My bet… He kidnapped her with the intent to have sex with her… And most likely kill her. This “hero” thing is far too absurd. He knew he screwed up and would probably be caught..and started telling people this story to cover his tracks and make it seem like a nice and easy accidental death. This guy is a predator, plain and simple.

    And to those saying nichole cable should have known it was a fake profile… She was 15 years old! A child! How could you put any blame on her.

  • Emily Clocke

    Poor girl :'(

  • Mendi Mayhem

    Senseless crime, in the true meaning of the phrase.

  • Carrie Krueger

    I suppose I’m naive for thinking that no-one would ever be stupid enough to actually plan something resembling the plot of Endless Love in order to be perceived as a “hero”. I stand corrected. I feel bad for the girl’s family.

  • Twisted1

    Week weed…that stuff is oregeno. I live in a state where smoking is legal but I don’t know where to get it. Lol I am sure I could ask my daughter and she would know. But then that would make me a shitty parent. :/

  • Twisted1

    Only problem is a death during the commission of a felony can still get you life or in some cases death.

  • Nichole Cable Update: Kyle Dube, Maine murder suspect, groped 15-yr.-old victim,
    affidavit says

    (CBS/AP) BANGOR, Maine – A newly released court document says Maine teenager
    Nichole Cable told her boyfriend that Kyle Dube, the man now charged in her
    death, tried to kiss and grope her the night before she disappeared.

    A search warrant affidavit released in Bangor on Thursday provides a detailed
    account of the investigation into the May 12 disappearance of 15-year-old
    Nichole Cable.

    Police say the 20-year-old Dube, of Orono, used a fake Facebook account to
    lure her out of her home with the promise of marijuana and ended up killing

    The affidavit includes text messages in which Cable tells her boyfriend that
    she tried pushing Dube off her, but he wouldn’t stop and ended up leaving a bite
    mark on her.

    Cable’s remains were found in a wooded area eight days after she went


  • Nick