Home > Assault > Kid Tells Grandma To Shut Up – Kid Gets Cut

Kid Tells Grandma To Shut Up – Kid Gets Cut

September 2, 2010 at 8:20 am by Jaded

Apple Valley, MN – Parbati Kalicharan ain’t about to take any lip from some smart-mouthed kid. When her 12-year-old granddaughter supposedly told her to “shut up,” Grandma K came unhinged. The girl was putting a puzzle together on the kitchen table when she got all lippy. This angered grandma, who was in the kitchen, where the knives and other pointy objects are stored. She walked over and grabbed the puzzle box lid, ripped it up and threw it away. The distraught child begged her grandmother to allow her to have the box back, she needed it so she could see the picture and finish the puzzle. Grandma just ripped it up into smaller pieces. She then swiped all the puzzle pieces and threw them in the trash, too. The girl said something like, “I don’t like you,” and crawled under the kitchen table. When she came out from underneath the table, grandma reportedly started chasing her around with a knife. Somehow, the girl ended up with a small gash inside one of her ears. Parbati didn’t deny having the knife in her hand as she chased the child, but claimed she was holding it by the blade, showing the handle to the girl while threatening to hit her with it. She denied cutting the child, and police say the child’s injury didn’t appear to be serious. Parbati was booked into jail on Saturday, charged with felony assault. She made bail on Monday and was released.

Tags: Child Abuse, felony assault, knife, Minnesota

34 Comments

Comments

V2 Cigs electronic cigarettes - Break Free From The Pack!

The views expressed in the comments are those of the comment writers and don't represent the views or opinions of D'D or its staff. Feel free to flag comments that may violate conditions outlined in our Disclaimer.

http://pulse.yahoo.com/_XKNLIAW7ZAVPUVLHORFEGOTI5Q slytherinangel

You mess with granny, you get cut. Seriously, kudos to that little kid for outrunning the old psycho bat and uh remind me not to be in the kitchen with my gramma when she’s being a raging loony.
Boughtthefarm

Oh yeah, I believe she was holding the knife by the blade. Did she have a cut on her hand??
beatlechick

The last time I got smart with my grandma, I got slapped in the face, not knifed. It makes me wonder how many violent video games this granny was playing before she decided to cut people.
Anonymous

Apparently that girl’s mother hasn’t taught her manners & while my grandma usually saved me from being spanked by my mom, I WOULD NEVER TALK BACK TO HER OR ANY ADULT AT ALL…

Granny, next time use your hands AS the weapon.
Sally Mischief

HA maybe that little ass hole will think twice before back talking…. kids these days have no respect and the grandma who was probably used to it got tired. Sounds like something MY grandma would do. lol
Abroad

To my undying shame, I once told my mother to “shut up”. She went very quiet on me and I was ready to take it back even before she told me to go to my room and not come out until I was ready to apologise……. Never did it again.
Abroad

To my undying shame, I once told my mother to “shut up”. She went very quiet on me and I was ready to take it back even before she told me to go to my room and not come out until I was ready to apologise……. Never did it again.
Abroad

To my undying shame, I once told my mother to “shut up”. She went very quiet on me and I was ready to take it back even before she told me to go to my room and not come out until I was ready to apologise……. Never did it again.
Anonymous

A couple of hours on Grand Theft Auto and I start cuttin’ people, too.
Anonymous

I would NEVER have told my grandma to shut up. I don’t know that she would have STABBED me for it… But I certainly wasn’t taking any chances, either!
Tundratot

I don’t think the kid “got it”. Even after Grandma took the box and tore it up, she was focused on the puzzle and getting the lid back? She hasn’t learned to read the situation, has she? The only reason we’re reading about this is because Grandma had a knife . . . if she’d taken a switch to the girl, it wouldn’t have made the news and the girl might still have been slashed.
Tundratot

I don’t think the kid “got it”. Even after Grandma took the box and tore it up, she was focused on the puzzle and getting the lid back? She hasn’t learned to read the situation, has she? The only reason we’re reading about this is because Grandma had a knife . . . if she’d taken a switch to the girl, it wouldn’t have made the news and the girl might still have been slashed.
Tundratot

I don’t think the kid “got it”. Even after Grandma took the box and tore it up, she was focused on the puzzle and getting the lid back? She hasn’t learned to read the situation, has she? The only reason we’re reading about this is because Grandma had a knife . . . if she’d taken a switch to the girl, it wouldn’t have made the news and the girl might still have been slashed.
guillotinegirl

When I look at her mugshot I can just picture her saying, “Now don’t make me slice you like a melon!”
Anonymous

I bet she won’t make that mistake again! What’s so crazy is in my family, the kid would have been in a world of trouble for pressing Gma’s nerves in the first place. lol

A knife chase was a bit much Grandma… I’m sure a wooden spoon would have sufficed

I can’t stand smart mouth kids who lay up in your house, eating your food, drinking your kool-aid, burning your electricity and dont offer shit but some lip.
aka jas

I make it a point to keep my body maintained so my kids cant out run me. I’ll getcha sucka. ;.)

Just sayin.
Anonymous

What a dirty whore… too much curry in her diet made her hot-headed? Why not just slap the piss out of the kid, no need to chase (and cut her) with a knife. That won’t earn you any respect.
aka jas

I love the way you did that. You were able to racially insult multiple races and then come back and say it was wrong! Bravo! BRAVO! You have a way with words.
Anonymous

In most circles, that’s known as sarcasm, Jas. You should look it up. I was calling Tar_Baby out on the stereotyping of an Eastern Indian person by offering up equally offensive stereotypes and asking if it would be okay to use those if the perp was African American or Mexican.
TAR_BABY

What a dirty whore… too much curry in her diet made her hot-headed? Why not just slap the piss out of the kid, no need to chase (and cut her) with a knife. That won't earn you any respect.
Anonymous

While I agree the knife was a bit much, the little smartass will think twice before she gives her grandmother lip again. In fact, I bet she sits with her back to the wall from now on. My grandmother grabbed me by the ear one time and dragged me home when I said something I wasn’t supposed to. That hurt like hell, and I never lipped off to her again. Kids just don’t know when to stop pushing it.
AMGallagher

That's funny! My mom used to to threaten us with the wooden spoon!
tenntitanfan

my kids know I have knives and guns (LOL) – they behave. Little brats run all over me like a car on the interstate but they know they better be respective when it’s serious time or around other adults!!
meechie

So if granny had been Mexican, it would have been too many tamales? Or if she were black, you would have used the old fried chicken excuse instead? Nationality/race has nothing to do with this.
Anonymous

I dont think its a good idea to get lippy or start a fight in the kitchen.. too many stabby pointy things around. Man o man,but gramma had enough of her mouth, and Im bettin this wasnt the 1st time that girl messed with gramma. I laughed and laughed. Changed my panties and laughed some more.God damn brat.
broken

I have a can of gasoline in my garage, along with a matchbox. Care to take a swig? And what kind of retarded name is ‘TAR_BABY’?

Anyway, this woman is a failure…on account of not dismembering the child. A mere cut to the ear…what a disgrace. She better put the knives down and take up something a tad sharper to get the job done. Ole’ age and all, she’s starting to slip, really…what a lack of precision and dedication to the art of murdering children…
Anonymous

Tar_Baby is “mixed race”: 1/2 racist, 1/2 idiot. As you did an excellently eloquent job of pointing out on the Vancouver-Acid thread. Broken, I salute you.

: D
Anonymous

Meechie, I thought your sarcasm was plenty clear.

Ironically, if you look through Tar_Baby’s posts on this site, it’s pretty clear that Tar_Baby WOULD not only think it was okay to say such a thing about a Mexican person or a black person, s/he would actually say those things.
aka jas

Your’e new huh? Sarcasm….oh honey I have made myself queen of sarcasm long long ago.

“Dont do as I do, do as I say” I hate that fucking mentality. Not only that but saying it sound as dumb as the thinking.

When bashing one racist you decided to show example by throwing racial stereotypes to make another feel wrong for doing so. How does that show intelligence or brilliance? Or even that you are better than another for doing the same thing. Did you read my post….that was sarcasm. Maybe YOU should look it up.
Kwumey

EPIC! bet that mouthy lil brat will think twice before spoutin off to grannie!!!
headonapike

Boy, you don’t want to piss her off. Look at that expression on her face. It looks like someone pissed in her cheerios, forced her to eat them, and made her wash them down with lemonade.
Ruby Tuesday

You know the entire story reads as though the whole lot of them have very little respect for each other. I loved my gran and was brought up to respect not only her but any adult. If I had back chatted her when I was a kid I’m pretty sure she would have dealt with me in a completely non- violent way, whilst making damn sure that I knew what I had said was wrong. I was always really upset if I thought I upset anyone in my family. My kids are the same with me – guess it’s just the way you bring them up.
Anonymous

I actually know the grandmother in this story; she used to work with my husband. While I can’t condone physically attacking children in any way, there may be more to this story. That particular grandchild has been notorious in the past for getting into trouble with family members and has been known to stage self-harm to enact various plots. I know that Parbati can certainly lose her temper but she loves her grandkids and it at least wouldn’t surprise me if the girl cut her own ear in order to get revenge on grandma for destroying the puzzle.
http://pulse.yahoo.com/_D5PKUBLEDATKIOTLCOF3M7KHGI Danielle

Damn! This takes talking back to a whole new level. Craziness.